Select Page

You’ve likely heard of 360-degree feedback being used as part of employee evaluations. Your boss, your direct reports and, in some cases, your peers give you feedback on how you’re performing in your role.

While it’s commonplace among some corporations, it’s practically unheard of in the educational industry when it comes to students being given the opportunity to evaluate their teachers. That is until recently.

As reported by The Washington Post, D.C. Public Schools is on the brink of implementing extensive changes in how teachers are trained and evaluated — changes that will be closely watched by other school systems across the nation to see if they will result in measurable results.

The school system has been experimenting with various forms of education reform during the past 10 years, with traditional methods such as workshops being replaced by weekly small group meetings attended by teachers who are coached with expertise in their subject matters. The small setting allows them the opportunity to ask relevant questions, bring up issues in their classrooms, and adjust lesson plans.

D.C., which was among the first school systems in the nation to use student test scores as a factor in teacher evaluations, will become among the first in recent years to incorporate student surveys to determine how well teachers are performing. Also, D.C. has plans to use school principals to observe teachers in the classroom — a departure from using independent evaluators.

The changes are scheduled for implementation during the 2016-17 school year. According to Kate Walsh, president of the National Council on Teacher Quality, an advocacy group, the changes in D.C. could be instrumental in inspiring change at other school systems.

“The movement that we’re seeing in D.C. has implications for the entire nation,” Walsh said. “Most districts think that the way you prepare for Common Core standards is to teach about instructional shifts in some kind of generic pedagogical way that really doesn’t mean a lot to teachers.

“If you develop a system where you’re learning how to make those shifts in the context of learning about ‘Romeo and Juliet,’ that becomes meaningful to teachers — and actionable,” she said.

Student surveys as part of teacher evaluations is not new, however, it hasn’t been widespread. As a result, the effectiveness of using them has not been closely reviewed. However, the Measures of Effective Teaching (MET) study determined that student perception surveys could be effective in measuring a teacher’s effectiveness.

According to the three-year study, which was sponsored by the Gates Foundation, there are several benefits to students evaluating teachers. Researchers concluded, “Although an individual student may have a less sophisticated understanding of effective instruction than a trained observer, student feedback has two other advantages that contribute to reliability: students see the teacher all year (and, therefore, are less susceptible to lesson to lesson variation), and the measures are averaged over 20 to 75 students, rather than 1 or 2 observers.”

In a nutshell, the study determined “students know an effective classroom when they experience one.”

Featured Articles

SFS New Administrator Training Registration

SFS New Administrator Training Registration

This training meets the evaluation training required by Indiana code. The training will be provided by experienced, licensed Indiana administrators that have helped administrators complete over 1 million evaluations since the new legislation in 2011.

read more
SFS Accreditation Enhancement and Features

SFS Accreditation Enhancement and Features

SFS Accreditation management product has grown exponentially in the past year based upon those suggestions from our early adopters, and we’re proud to be able to highlight some of our most popular features for you.

read more
Summer:  Time to Refresh!

Summer: Time to Refresh!

Ah, June. The promise of a whole summer lies ahead. Students are more than ready for a break, teachers are finishing end of year tasks, and administrators might even get the...

read more
Quality Program and Curriculum Evaluation

Quality Program and Curriculum Evaluation

SFS can customize a rubric based upon best standards or your curricular standards. This allows a district to track areas of strength and challenge within a program, and be documented and utilized to guarantee excellent programming to families.

read more
Innovative STEM Learning with JASON

Innovative STEM Learning with JASON

Jason Learning turns the classroom, home and community groups into science, technology and math labs. JASON Learning has been providing curriculum and learning experiences in STEM for K-12 students for over 30 years.

read more
From the desk of the CEO

From the desk of the CEO

Hello, I am Todd Whitlock, CEO and Co-Founder of Standard For Success. It has been a year since the education world was turned upside down.  As we were presenting thought leadership sessions and meeting with school leaders they were discussing closing and scrambling to put resources and procedures in place to get through the end of the year.

read more
CARES Act and Education Stabilization Fund for Schools

CARES Act and Education Stabilization Fund for Schools

Looking to Maximize your CARES Funding to Accelerate Learning? One of our SFS team members can help you sort through the process and understand how these funds can be used for SFS products and services, as well as for other initiatives in your school or district.

read more