Select Page

The following is an excerpt from Dr Dianna Whitlock’s published book, “Teacher Evaluation as a Growth Process.” To purchase the full book, visit Amazon or Barnes&Noble.

Part 1, Chapter 2: Why Evaluate

The beginning of many educators’ careers saw little consistency in the teacher evaluation process (Andrews, 2016, Powerpoint slide 3).  Often times evaluation day would look something like this:  an administrator (likely the principal) would tell a beginning teacher that they would stop by for an observation sometime that week.  The teacher would then prepare many visuals and engaging activities for the upcoming lesson, so the students would be responsive and involved.  After a showboat lesson, the administrator would leave a post-it note on the teacher’s desk saying something like, Enjoyed the lesson, keep up the good work! The administrator would then complete a checklist for the teacher, place a copy in their mailbox, and the teacher would sign and return it.  This would likely be the last interaction concerning evaluation for the year.

As an elementary teacher, I was guilty of saving my best lessons for evaluation week.  These lessons usually involved candy or cereal of some kind to be used as manipulatives.  The reasons for this are fairly obvious. The kids were excited, the activities were endless: graphing, sorting, adding, subtracting, etc., and the best overarching bribe of all, If you do a good job and complete all of the activities, you can eat them at the end of the lesson. The idea here being that if it was a super-fun, hands-on lesson where kids were engaged (or maybe just hungry), you could wow your administrator and likely not suffer an observation for another year.

While my colleagues and I agreed that the positive reinforcement that stemmed from a summary of a job well done was pleasant, true constructive feedback was limited. In the 1990’s and early 2000’s, evaluations were only truly utilized and monitored for teacher dismissal. In addition, there was a “lack of urgency” (Andrews, 2016, Powerpoint slide 5) when analyzing teacher and administrator evaluations, as schools and legislators concentrated on implementing school improvement initiatives that focused solely on instructional practices and student achievement scores.

Why then, is it important to change the way we evaluate?  More importantly, why is it essential to change the conversation around teacher evaluation?  Perhaps the quote below explains it best:

“Improvement usually means doing something that we have never done before.”

Shigeo Shingo

Legislative mandates are beginning to force the hand of administrators to adjust evaluation practices in their schools due to increased reporting components. Administrators can no longer skip evaluations for years at a time, nor count the post-it note mentioned above as constructive feedback.  Administrators are now being asked to report teacher evaluation data as a summative number to their state agencies for the first time in their careers.

To continue reading, click here to purchase the full book.

Featured Articles

Education Advanced acquires Standard For Success

Education Advanced acquires Standard For Success

Education Advanced, Inc. (EAI), a leading provider of operations management and workflow solutions for K-12 school districts, announced today the acquisition of Indiana-based Standard for Success (SFS), an independently owned company, founded by teachers, to support educators and administrators with software, services, and solutions.

read more
Graduation Pathways FAQ

Graduation Pathways FAQ

Indiana school advisors, administrators, counselors, and principals all have the important task of tracking graduation pathways for their students. In fact, the Indiana State...

read more
Make the Most of an Evaluation Walkthrough

Make the Most of an Evaluation Walkthrough

In order to provide the most effective learning environment possible, educators need ongoing evaluation and feedback. An evaluation walkthrough is an assessment tool that you can use to provide valuable data regarding how well the implementation of standards-based instruction is occurring. A walkthrough protocol needs to be established to make sure the data is retrieved, examined, and analyzed as efficiently as possible. The following explains the steps to take to successfully implement this process.

read more
Coronavirus and the Impact on High School Graduation

Coronavirus and the Impact on High School Graduation

The beginning of the pandemic in 2020 had major unexpected effects on many aspects of our lives. Unfortunately, this had a huge impact on children’s education, which moved students and educators to remote classrooms online instead of the traditional in-class school days we are all accustomed to.

read more
Seven Factors That Improve Teacher Evaluation

Seven Factors That Improve Teacher Evaluation

In Seven Ways to Make Improving Teacher Evaluation Worth the Work, a piece written by Nicole Gerber form the National Council on Teacher Quality, list 7 key ideas that will improve teacher evaluation and therefore have the potential to drive teacher and student improvement. She indicates that according to research study, it is important to adhere to research-based principles to make the process work. She then goes on to spotlight seven key principles in the teacher evaluation process.

read more